In recent years, lab-grown or synthetic diamonds have been an attractive choice to mined diamonds. They have the same chemical make-up, visual fire, and a lot of times a much lower price tag. With options like that, it may be appealing"”especially to more modern buyers looking to get the most value. But are synthetic diamonds worth it? Your value system will determine the response.

Rare Carat is a pioneer in assisting clients in making well-informed choices, ranking as America's top source of objective guidance on diamond engagement rings. Rare Carat provides the resources and transparency required to make informed purchases, comparing over a million diamonds from reliable merchants, whether you're looking for a natural or lab-grown diamond ring.

Here's a fair assessment of the benefits and drawbacks of synthetic diamonds, along with how Rare Carat guarantees that you can shop with confidence.

1. Pro: More Diamond for Less Money

Cost is one of the biggest benefits of lab created diamonds. Synthetic diamonds cost about 50% less than their natural diamonds of the same size and quality. This allows you to either save a lot of money or upgrade to larger carat, better clarity, or finer cut without breaking the bank. With Rare Carat's AI-powered diamond grading & price scoring, buyers can easily find the synthetic diamonds that offer the best value to them, while still allowing us all to enjoy high-end beauty at a lower-cost.

2. Con: Lower Resale Value

Natural diamonds have a higher likelihood of retaining resale value than synthetic diamonds, while a lab-grown diamond may offer more value up front - it does not hold long-term resale value in the same way as mined diamonds. The resale market for lab-grown stones is still being developed and generally carries much lower returns than that of mined diamonds. 

Nevertheless, some buyers may see the emotional and visual value of a diamond ring as more important than resale value consideration. With Rare Carat's warranty and methods of supportive resources, resale value is less of an issue with buyers prioritizing quality and affordability.

3. Pro: Identical in Appearance and Composition

Lab-grown diamonds are identical chemically, physically, and optically to mined diamonds. They cannot be distinguished with the naked eye"”even experienced jeweler's need special equipment to differentiate them.

With free certified gemologist reviews from Rare Carat, customers receive expert evaluations on GIA-certified diamonds, ensuring clarity, cut, and color match expectations"”all regardless of whether the diamond is lab-grown or mined.

4. Con: Emotional and Symbolic Preferences Still Vary

For some customers, the scarcity and sentimental worth of mined diamonds serves as an emotional anchor. While this may be subjective, it is worth noting that not all consumers gravitate towards lab-grown stones for Weddings or Engagement ceremonies.  

Rare Carat supports either direction, with the goal of education and tools to help align to what buyers really want. Whether it is tradition or non-traditional, the traditions, both approach and education are both respected and supported equally!

5. Pro: Ethical and Environmentally Friendly

Unlike mined diamonds that are formed underground, lab-grown diamonds are made in high-tech labs without mining.  Lab-grown, therefore, acts in a more ethical and sustainable manner than, mined diamonds for the environmentally-conscious buyer.  This eliminates quite a lot of the social and ecological concerns that are often associated with diamond mining.

Rare Carat labels each diamond's origin and allows you to filter by type to assist costumers make their decision when shopping for based on those ethics, but not on the sparkle or combined beauty of the gem.

6. Pro: Transparent Comparison with Rare Carat Tools

With more than a million diamonds to compare, including both natural and lab-grown diamonds, Rare Carat makes it easy to see side-by-side variations in terms of cost, specifications, and deal scores. The information required to confidently interpret those specifications is provided by their 4 Cs Diamond Buying Guide.

To break through the clutter, shoppers can view HD videos, thorough listings, and side-by-side comparisons. No pressure to sell. Only current data and facts.

7. Pro: Full-Service Experience from Purchase to Protection

Rare Carat provides full-service assistance, eliminating the usual stress associated with expensive purchases:

  • 30-day money-back promise
  • Returns are free and insured shipping
  • Free resizing for a year (eternity bands are not included after 30 days)
  • Options for a lifetime warranty and an extended care plan

With thousands of verified 5-star reviews and professional advice, it's a luxury service without the markup.

8. Pro: Trusted by Thousands of Satisfied Customers

Rare Carat has a 4.9★ rating on Trustpilot and Google Business and has received overwhelming reviews for its pricing honesty, customer service and transparency. Many purchasers state that it has helped them make lab-grown purchases where they were able to purchase larger and better quality stones than initially planned on without compromising, while staying on budget.

The level of trust is certainly at a high enough level that Rare Carat is the best place to shop at Rare Carat for synthetic diamonds and natural diamonds.

Final Word

Are lab-created diamonds a good investment? If you're looking for beauty responsible sourcing, and great deals, the answer is yes"”with Rare Carat's smart tools and expert help to guide you. The website takes away the guesswork, shows you real savings, and gets you stunning diamonds"”whether they're made in a lab or dug up from the ground.