Choose the Best Pillow in 2022: Definitive Buying Guide

Pillow is the basic bedding requirement for anyone but there are different types of pillows available today that finding the right one can be downright confusing. Memory foam, microbead, water pillows are an option in today’s saturated pillow and bedding markets.

No single type of pillow is made for every need, unfortunately. We have choices to make – lots and lots of opportunities to choose from.

The wide variety and types of pillows available today are most easily categorized by what they’re filled with. A quality fabric pillowcase or shell is an essential component, but the filling dictates its general character.

Pillow’s mixture makes it the thing and feels the way it does. A pillowcase with a zippered opening allows adjusting filling to suit the personal preferences. These can easily change softness/firmness and loft (height) by adding or removing padding from the pillow.

Not all pillow types offer this kind of flexibility, but if someone is willing to get hands-on, they can purchase filling and a case separately for a DIY pillow! Each pillow filling has its advantages/disadvantages and appeals to a unique audience of sleepy heads. Let’s check out some of the online available models.

Best Pillows for You

Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow

The Coop Home Goods Adjustable Pillow is the best option for anyone who likes to create a custom pillow without paying a load of money. It’s filled with CertiPUR-US certified, non-toxic memory foam and microfiber, and you can add as considerable or as little fill as you require to achieve the perfect loft for your sleeping status. An extra half-pound bag of stuffing is included with your pillow.

  • Best for: All sleepers
  • Fill: Memory foam and microfiber blend
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Dimensions: 30×20 inches or 30×26 inches
  • Care: Machine wash (without fill)
  • Warranty: 5 years
PROSCONS
Easy to adjust height and density, 5-year warranty and 100-night trial, Hypoallergenic and cruelty-freeToo dense for smaller-framed people, Off-gassing smell can be potent

Casper Original Sleep Pillow

If you enjoy the plushness of a down pillow without the allergies and animal-sourced contents, the best alternative is the Casper Original Sleep Down Alternative Pillow. It’s filled with hypoallergenic microfibers, pushing it as soft as authentic down pillows but with far better synthetic materials.

  • Best for : All sleeping positions
  • Fill: Microfiber
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Dimensions: 18×26 inches or 18×34 inches with 2-inch gusset
  • Care: Machine wash (without fill)
  • Warranty: 1 year
PROSCONS
Balance of softness and support, Adapts to all sleep styles, Machine-washableFrequent fluffing may be required, Only comes with a 30-day trial

Purple Harmony Pillow

Purple’s top-of-the-line Harmony Pillow may not accommodate the conventional definition of the best luxury pillow, but we display it’s worthy of the distinction. Like the company’s high-rated Purple Mattress, the Purple Harmony pillow features the company’s signature Purple Grid to deliver tailored help for your head and neck. At the core of the pad is ventilated Talalay latex to improve the airflow of the Purple Grid. All of that is wrapped by a moisture-wicking snap mesh cover.

  • Best for: Hot sleepers, side sleepers
  • Fill: Talalay latex and hyper-elastic polymer
  • Firmness: Medium-soft
  • Dimensions: 26×17 inches, with either 6.5-inch or 7.5-inch loft
  • Care: Spot-treat
  • Warranty: 1 year
PROSCONS
Extremely soft and supportive, Breeze mesh cover great for cooling, Customer service is excellentMay be too soft for some

Utopia Bedding Gusseted Pillow Duo

The Utopia Bedding gusseted pillows confirm you don’t have to surrender quality when purchasing pillows on a budget. The Utopia Bedding gusseted pillow duo comes vacuum-sealed and takes up to 72 hours to ultimately expand. Once they fully puff up, they’re a far cry from the flattened shape they initially arrive in. These plush-down alternative pillows are stuffed with 950 to 1,250 grams of poly fiberfill. In addition, they feature a poly-cotton outer fabric and a two-inch quilted gusset edge in your choice of six colors if you opt to skip the pillow covers.

  • Best for: Small budgets
  • Fill: Polyester
  • Firmness: Plush
  • Dimensions: 18×26 inches or 18×36 inches with 2-inch gusset
  • Care: Spot clean or hand-wash
  • Warranty: 1 year
PROSCONS
Versatile for combo sleepers, Great-value quality and comfort, Available in different colorsCan’t buy pillows individually, Need time to fluff after unpacking

Tempur-Pedic Tempur Cloud Pillow

Tempur-Pedic pillows are mere as supporting as the brand’s popular mattresses, and here that’s down to the usefulness of Tempur material. In addition, it’s contouring and cushioning, so your crown will be perfectly nestled during sleep. Still, like any suitable back and stomach sleeper pillow, the Tempur Cloud Pillow presents a suitable loft to keep your head without pushing your neck forwards (and out of alignment) during sleep. It’s also created with a removable and washable cover, so you can more efficiently keep it in a good state throughout its lifespan.

  • Best for: Stomach and back sleepers
  • Fill: Tempur
  • Firmness: Soft
  • Dimensions: 24×15.3×5”
  • Care: Machine washable cover
  • Warranty: 5-year limited
PROSCONS
Contours to your head, Supportive yet soft, Hyopallergenic pillowNo trial period or returns

Beckham Hotel Collection Gel Pillow

A little caveat is that you can only purchase this pillow in pairs, but you can always accumulate the second pillow for a guest room or a substitute down the line if you only want to sleep on one. Another drawback is the lack of a warranty, but a 30-day money-back assurance does involve.

  • Best for: Hotel plushness at home
  • Fill: Gel fiber
  • Firmness: Plush
  • Dimensions: 18×27 inches or 20×36 inches
  • Care: Machine-wash
  • Warranty: N/A
PROSCONS
Hypoallergenic down alternative, Machine-washable, Over 157,000 Amazon reviewsNo warranty included

Layla Kapok Pillow

Copper bedding is created to wick away body heat and stop the ripening of bacteria on your skin, among other advantages. If you’re keen to push a copper-infused pillow to assist in being comfortable and reenergized, then the best pillow for all is the very well-known Layla Kapok Pillow. The outer surface of Layla’s cushion for sleeping features a polyester/viscose mixture with copper fibers woven in for cooling and antimicrobial properties. The inner fill combines reactive memory foam and lightweight Kapok fibers. It delivers a high loft ideal for most side sleepers, but you can remove and adjust the filling to your liking.

  • Best for: Night sweats; odor control; hot sleepers; side and back sleepers
  • Fill: Kapok fiber and memory foam
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Dimensions: 18.5×28.5 inches or 18.5×36 inches
  • Care: Machine wash (without fill)
  • Warranty: 5 years
PROSCONS
120-night trial, Adjustable fill for the perfect loft, Cooling and comfortableStomach sleepers may not like it

Boll & Branch Down Pillow

Coined by Boll & Branch as “the internet’s best down pillow,” the sturdy version is precisely for those of you who can only rest comfortably on a very thick and robust bed pillow. The Boll & Branch Down Pillow is loaded with sustainably and ethically sourced goose down from US ranches. The down is triple cleaned for maximum hygienic, then put inside a ‘down-proof’ organic cotton shell. That suggests you shouldn’t judge anything poking through the cover when you’re sleeping your head and face on this sumptuous pillow. The design incorporates a three-chamber construction, which allows the pad to keep its body throughout the time you employ it

  • Best for: All sleepers who want a down pillow
  • Fill: Ethically sourced down
  • Firmness: Soft, medium, firm
  • Dimensions: 20 x 28 (standard), 20 x 36 (king)
  • Care: Machine wash or spot clean
  • Warranty: None
PROSCONS
Full and plump shape, Very supportive, Choice of sizes and firmnessNo warranty

EPABO Contoured Memory Foam Pillow

If you suffer from sleep-related neck discomfort, then the best pillow for you is an orthopedic fashion. Unlike traditional pads, this contoured pillow features a dip in the center to nestle your head and keep your shoulders, neck, and back aligned no matter your sleeping status. In addition, the EPABO Contoured Memory Foam Pillow is densely-packed with memory foam and incorporates a removable foam insert should the loft be too elevated for you. This bed pillow is also nestled in a hypoallergenic polyester and rayon case.

  • Best for: Neck pain; good head and neck support
  • Fill: Memory foam
  • Firmness: Medium
  • Dimensions: 21x13x3.9 inches, 24x15x4.6 inches, 24x15x4.8 inches
  • Care: Machine wash (without fill)
  • Warranty: 30 days
PROSCONS
Proper alignment for all sleep styles, Adjustable loft, Cheaper than similar pillowsTakes times to adjust to it, Warranty is only 30 days

Brooklinen Down Pillow

The Brooklinen Down Pillow is the company’s most delicate and fluffiest choice for sleeping. That’s because this best-seller has been created to deliver support and plush comfort across a spectrum of sleeping statuses. Select from two sizes (standard or king) and three firmness grades: plus, mid-plush, and firm. The plush pillow is wholly loaded with down clusters and is the best alternative for stomach sleepers. Meanwhile, flank sleepers can either go for the mid-plush pillow with equal portions of feathers and down or the firm pillow with a more elevated ratio of feathers to down.

  • Fill: Down clusters and feathers
  • Firmness: Plush, mid-plush, or firm
  • Dimensions: 20×26 inches or 20×36 inches
  • Care: Spot treat or dry clean
  • Warranty: 2 years
PROSCONS
Two sizes and three firmness levels, Free returns for up to one year, Great for side and stomach sleepersNot ideal for back sleepers, Possible unpleasant outgassing smell

Various Kinds of Pillows

Polyester Fiberfill Pillows

Many-a-times referred to as Poly-fil, its trademarked name, fiberfill is the cheapest option on the list. It tends to flatten out with us, unfortunately, and won’t last as long as other types of pillows. What’s more, polyester products are manufactured

Advantages Disadvantages
Dirt cheapPolyester fill clumps quickly requiring frequent readjustment and lose elasticity with use
Easy to cleanShort life span
Potentially hazardous to the health of the user & the environment

Feather Pillows

Feathers’ and quills naturally begin to align with each other or lay flat. Over time this makes the pillow flat and uncomfortable. To prevent this, producers often add down clusters to the feathers to slow down the degeneration.

Advantages Disadvantages
Cheap15% of owners complaint a lingering and unpleasant odour.
Cuddly and lightRequires consistent fluffing to maintain its loft decrease the effect of quills flattening
SustainableDifficult to wash and clean
Biodegradable and recyclable

Memory Foam Pillows

Memory foam is pretty neat. If ever felt it, you know what I mean: It’s magical the way it retains its shape. It’s this “magic” that makes them so accessible; people are immediately impressed with the way memory foam feels.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Doesn’t clumpChemical odour
Doesn’t require fluffingPotentially dangerous “off-gassing.”
Offers good supportNot malleable/moldable
No loft adjustment
Builds up and retains body heat

Buckwheat Pillows

First, let me be entirely transparent. It’s pure love. I have tried different types of pillows, and I think nothing beats an all-natural, traditional buckwheat pillow.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Superior support to neck and backBuckwheat hulls always make a rustling noise when shifted
Constructed of all-natural compostable materialsMassive — a 20×26″ buckwheat pillow weighs around 8 pounds
Breathable and promotes airflow – stay coolToo firm for some.
Long life-span
Moldable/malleable
Holds shape and provides terrific support for your head, neck and shoulders

Microbead Pillows

Microbead pillows are filled with something called “uniform polymer particles,” which look like little white beads. They are the best synthetic alternative to buckwheat hull pillows, and they share a lot of the same characteristics. They both promote airflow. They’re somewhat malleable as well.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Breathable-keeps cool at nightChemical odour and potentially dangerous “off-gassing.”
Moldable/malleableNo variety of firmness or loft (they’re mostly medium firm, medium loft)
It holds its shape and offers excellent support for your head, neck and shouldersShort life span

Latex pillow filling

Latex pillows are becoming quite popular. They offer excellent support for your head and neck while retaining a soft feel. They’re also relatively breathable providing a new surface for your tired head. Latex pillows have an owner satisfaction rating rivalling that of our favourite type, buckwheat pillows.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Great supportSlight “rubbery” odour
Semi-breathable Not moldable — no matter what you try, these things will bounce back into their rubbery shape
Stays coolToo dense and heavy to be considered “cuddly.”

Water Pillows

Water pillows contain, you guessed it, water. Most water-filled pads are simply a plastic reservoir wrapped with polyester foam or down alternative fiberfill. Water pillows are popular due to their ability to provide unchanging, reliable support.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Supportive , water pillow will consistently keep the head elevated at just the right level all night long.Not moldable
Pain relief, Johns Hopkins study gives evidence of a genuine benefit.Water pillow was covered in a super soft fill that pushed upward awkwardly into the side of the face.
Adjustable Leaks (potentially) — A wet mattress and flat pillow aren’t conducive to good rest!
Not many pillow types are flexible.which is massive advantageHeavy — water isn’t the lightest of pillow filling!

Kapok Pillows

Kapok, or ceiba pentandra, is a tropical tree native to Mexico that flowers, producing a fluffy, cotton-like material containing hundreds of seeds. This light brown, soft fibre is sometimes referred to as silk cotton. Kapok’s qualities have made it very popular for filling pillows, upholstery, and even life preservers. Its use has dramatically declined since the introduction of polyester/polyurethane foams.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Free of the potentially toxic materials in many foam pillowsExtremely flammable
Cruelty-free — the practice of gathering feathers and down for use in pillows is far from humane and kapok, well… it’s not an animal!Quickly develop lumps, much like polyester foam pillows do
Compostable and biodegradableNot moldable, does not hold its shape

Cotton Pillows

Given cotton’s ubiquity, one would assume that cotton-filled pillows would be reasonably accessible. Popular new synthetic types of pillows like memory foam and polyfill have changed the market. These materials have relegated cotton to a minority position. A cotton pillow is a safe and preferable alternative to petroleum-based pillow filling like memory or polyfoam that is potentially toxic.

AdvantagesDisadvantages
Safe: cotton pillows do not contain the potentially toxic materials found in many foam pillowsWith use, the filling clumps and flattens
Odour freeNot moldable
Cooler than many types of pillows like memory foamDoes not hold its shape
Cruelty-free — cotton pillows provide no animal productsLacks the support that some other types of pillows can provide.
Compostable and biodegradable